Best Volumizing Mascara in 2023 – Volumizing Mascara Reviews and Ratings

Best Volumizing Mascara in 2023 – Volumizing Mascara Reviews and Ratings
We looked at a selection of the most popular volumizing mascaras on the market for color selection, ingredients, brush choice, brand name, special features, cost, reputation of the brand and customer reviews. The three mascaras that we have featured below topped the charts in all the categories. Any one of them would be an excellent addition to your makeup kit.
Best Volumizing Mascara

1. Simply Naked Beauty

Best Overall Volumizing Mascara

5/5 Product Rating
3D mascara has gotten very popular due to the effects it can have even on thin, sparse lashes.

This 3D Fiber Lash mascara by Simply Naked Beauty features brand new packaging and an improved formula that is designed to add plenty of volume to your lashes.

It also adds length to them as well which is common among volumizing mascara. It is smudge resistant and water resistant as well so you don’t end up with raccoon eyes if you get caught in the rain, yawn or even cry.

This mascara wears all day long so you won’t have to reapply it while you are running errands or working. It is made from natural, non-toxic ingredients that condition and strengthen your eye lashes.

It goes on easily; just three simple steps and your lashes will be transformed. Because of the natural ingredients, you don’t have to worry about your eyes becoming irritated. Even those who wear contacts can safely use this wonderful mascara.

It is made with Green Tea and is SLS and Paraben free. In addition, it has never been tested on animals. Enjoy the free ebook that contains tips and instructions and a protective case for carrying your mascara with you.

Linda Krantz

2. Endlessly Beautiful

Best Overall Volumizing Mascara – Runner Up

4.7/5 Product Rating
Endlessly Beautiful brings you a volumizing mascara that is sure to please.

Wearers will be able to create beautiful looks for daytime and night without worry of clumping, flaking or smearing.

It is made with a water resistant formula that lasts up to 12 hours long without having to be re-applied.

It is easy to remove as well. The unique 2 headed brush works together to create stunning eyelashes that you will be thrilled with.

This product uses superior natural beeswax and lecithin that will nourish and condition your natural lashes. It is cruelty free and not tested on animals.

Users will get instant, stunning results from the mascara, primer and conditioner that will have people taking notice of how great your eyes look.

Linda Krantz

3. It’s So BIG

Best Budget Volumizing Mascara

4.5/5 Product Rating
This perfect volumizing mascara doesn’t smudge or flake and can be worn all day without getting mascara underneath your eyes.

This unique formula curls and thickens your lashes along with adding length too.

The hourglass brush shape has both long and short bristles to keep the mascara from clumping.

You can even work out with this mascara and not have to worry about it running or smearing. Raccoon eyes will be a thing of the past.

This mascara is cruelty free and the company offers a no risk, money back guarantee for their customers.

If you’re not happy for any reason, they will refund your money, no questions asked.

Linda Krantz

Volumizing Mascara Buying Guide

Volumizing Mascara Reviews

Things to Consider

volumizing-mascara1There are several things that you will want to look at when you are comparing one volumizing mascara to another. We have listed these points below.

  • Formula and Wand – Is One more Important? – No, one is not more important than the other. You can have a terrific formula but if the wand is substandard the mascara will still not apply correctly and more than likely you will switch. The shape and design of the brush impacts how the mascara applies. As to which type of brush you like better, that is strictly up to personal preference.
  • Shape of the Brush – There are many different types of brushes on the market. Mascaras have many different types that they use with their formulas. You may find mascara with large, “bushy” brushes, small thin bristles, and some even have more than one type of brush in the same mascara. Most often, a mascara brush that has short bristles are much easier to keep control of.
  • Bottom Lash Brushes – More often than not, volumizing mascara will go on the top lashes but not the bottom. This is due to avoiding the spider eye look unless that is your goal. A small brush with very short bristles is perfect for applying mascara to the bottom lashes. Many volumizing mascaras have a main brush for the top lashes and at the other end have a short bristle brush for applying just the right amount of mascara to your bottom lashes so they look natural and terrific.
  • Mascara Flaking – If you are having trouble with your mascara flaking there are two possible causes. One is that your mascara is old. The other is because you are trying to use the wrong formula. A thin formula that is meant to encourage lengthening is not meant to make the lashes thicker, so adding the amount needed to achieve the same look a true volumizing mascara would give you can result in the excess flaking off.
  • Brand Name – A company’s reputation is very important when it comes to ensuring good quality. While some off brand mascaras may be just fine, you might be better off sticking to the better known and established brands.

Types of Mascara Brushes

volumizing-mascara2The type of brush your mascara has influences the result you end up with once the mascara is applied. Pay attention to the shape of the mascara brush when you are researching different formulas. The shape of the brush should be shown on the front of the package so you know what you are purchasing. We have listed the most common mascara brushes below with the characteristics of each.

  • Mascara Comb – The teeth on a mascara comb are evenly spaced and are designed to separate and define the lashes.
  • Large Bristle Brush – All the bristles on this type of brush are packed closely together even if they are long in length. This type of brush is used to create volume and covers a lot of lashes at one time. This is the type of brush that is most often included in volumizing mascara.
  • Curved Brush – This arched brush is shaped similar to the natural curve of the eye. It is supposed to create curl in the lash but unless you use an eyelash curler first, you won’t really get much curl even if the mascara says it is curling mascara and a curling brush.
  • Spherical shape brush– This small ball of bristles is used for precise mascara application and is good for separating and defining the lashes.
  • Tapered Brush – These densely packed bristles has a narrow brush tip the provides total coverage and precise application as well.
  • Small Bristle Brush – This tiny brush is perfect for the bottom lashes due to its small size and well defined bristles.

Try to match the brush and the mascara’s formula for the best application. If you find a mascara formula you like but you don’t like the brush, you can purchase a brush separately that matches the type of formula you are using.

Mascara Safety Tips

Mascara should be carefully used and handled especially since it is being used on your eyelashes. There are some important safety tips that you want to keep in mind when you are purchasing a mascara and brush for your makeup kit.

  1. Replace your mascara brush every 2-3 months. Waiting any longer than that can put you at risk of introducing bacteria that has gotten onto the brush into your eyes which will create a big problem.
  2. If the mascara smells bad, is discolored or changes in consistency, replace it.
  3. Store your mascara in a cool place, preferably below 29 degrees Celsius which will minimize the growth of bacteria.
  4. NEVER share mascara with another person, even if you know them really well or they are relatives.
  5. Never go to bed with your mascara on. Remove it properly so your eyes do not become irritated or infected. A good quality eye makeup remover that doesn’t require you to rub your eyes harshly.
  6. volumizing-mascara3

  7. Be careful when applying mascara. Not being careful or being in a rush can result in poking your eye with the brush which can cut the cornea or scratch it.


With all of the mascara formulas on the market, finding the right volumizing mascara for your specific needs and preferences can be a real challenge. Knowing a few things about mascara and what each type offers is one of the best ways to be able to sort through the choices and get rid of the ones that don’t meet your needs.

Volumizing mascara is just one type of many that you can choose from. Many people use several different types depending on what their goals are for their eye makeup look. If your specific goals are to thicken your lashes, draw attention to your eyes and create a beautiful look where your lashes really stand out, a volumizing mascara is the way to go.

The three choices we featured above are a great place to start. All three of them are excellent quality volumizing mascara that will provide the results you are looking for. The brushes are good quality and they offer a selection of colors to choose from as well.

If none of the ones we shared with you are what you’re looking for, use the information in this guide to research other brands to see which one will fit your needs the best. Since mascara is going on your eyes, it is paramount that you choose one that is of good quality and from a reputable brand.

Don’t forget to check out the customer reviews and comments when you are researching. These reviews come from people that have purchased the mascara and used it so their experiences are very valuable to you. It’s a great way to get some detailed information that the sales site doesn’t usually provide.


  1. Mia Adora –
  2. Elizabeth Mott –
  3. Caught My Eye –

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply