Best Mattress Protector in 2023 – Mattress Protector Reviews and Ratings

Best Mattress Protector in 2023 – Mattress Protector Reviews and Ratings
In this review, we’ll look at three of the best mattress protectors out there and figure out just what it is that makes one mattress protector better than the other, ensuring your new mattress will stay new. In today’s market, a mattress can cost an upward of two thousand dollars. Despite this, the actual product which protects it from getting damaged over time can cost as little as twenty dollars.
Best Mattress Protector

1. Coop Home Goods

Best Overall Mattress Protector

5/5 Product Rating
Despite its bamboo-derived status perhaps suggesting otherwise, this particular mattress protector does its job well while remaining soft and undetectable, ensuring your mattress stays protected while you still manage to get a quality night’s sleep despite the protector’s presence. This Coop Home Goods mattress protector does a great job of covering all of the bases, which is what makes it one of the best in the business. Believe it or not, many mattress protectors will often only protect your mattress against certain types of damage (stains but not scratches, etc.), making them less suitable for a wider variety of folks. This particular protector; however, is sure to be able to protect your mattress against anything that might get thrown its way. Not only is this a great representation of quality, it makes it one of the safer purchases out there, being that you don’t have to worry about getting the wrong mattress protector to meet your needs.

For example, it does a great job of fighting against stains. While this isn’t too exciting if you never have food or drinks in the bedroom, those of us who do will likely appreciate the piece of mind this characteristic can offer. The mattress protector also protects your mattress from allergens and other microorganisms. While the unit itself will certainly come in contact with the dirt your mattress otherwise would, this shouldn’t be nearly as huge of an issue, being that washing a mattress protector is a whole lot easier than washing a mattress. And, because it is hypoallergenic, you’ll find that it actually collects a whole lot less of these microorganisms in the first place. This is obviously a huge advantage, being that it won’t be too big a deal in the event that you forget to clean it.

Lastly, and this is quite rare to find in such a product, you’ll actually find the protector to be comfortable. Now, if you’ve used a variety of mattress protectors in the past, you’ll know that most don’t only refrain from making you more comfortable, but are often liable to make you less comfortable. All of these features go on to set the product apart from nearly every other unit on the market.

Sarah Lytle

2. Luna Premium

Best Overall Mattress Protector – Runner Up

4.8/5 Product Rating
This particular mattress protector is quite similar to the last one we looked at. Again, you can expect it to keep your mattress free of stains through its waterproof status. This is a huge deal, being that stains account for a large portion of mattress mishaps due solely to how easy it is to make a stain in the first place. This also makes the protector great for children who have not yet mastered the art of potty training. You’ll also find this product to be rather comfortable as well.

Because both mattress protectors are so similar in the features they offer, whether you choose to go with one over the other truly all comes down to a matter of brand recognition. If you’ve come to love everything released by the Luna brand, you may decide to go with this particular product. I will; however, make note of the fact that this particular protector comes with a ten-year warranty, as opposed to the Coop Home Goods’ mattress protector, whose warranty lasts an entire fifteen years. Still, both products are completely viable options.

Sarah Lytle

3. SafeRest Classic Plus

Best Budget Mattress Protector

4.7/5 Product Rating
While the two above protectors are quite similar in nature, the SafeRest Classic Plus can be considered as being in its own category altogether. For example, while the above two protectors may actually increase your overall level of comfort, this protector tends to do nothing at all in this regard. Still, this is certainly a nice quality when you consider that the average protector lowers your overall level of comfort quite dramatically. The SafeRest Classic Plus is certainly above par in this sense. It also only comes with a three-year warranty, which is quite a bit lower than the other two products.

However, in terms of getting the most bang for your buck, it doesn’t get a whole lot better than the SafeRest Classic Plus. For only twenty dollars, you’ll be getting a mattress protector which trumps the quality of products which can be had for up to twice its cost. Assuming you’re willing to skip on a good warranty and already find your mattress comfortable as it is, this mattress protector will easily prove to be your best and most frugal option.

Sarah Lytle

Mattress Protector Buying Guide

Mattress Protector Reviews

What is a Mattress Protector?

Mattress Protector1While it’s safe to say that finding a mattress protector whose quality can trump that of either of the above three will be a rather tricky ordeal, you may have your own set of needs which you feel aren’t covered by the above list. If that’s the case, it may be beneficial to do some shopping for yourself. When doing so, keeping the below considerations in mind can ensure you still walk away with the best product you can possibly get your hands on.

What are you protecting against?

Liquid resistance is likely the closest thing to a standard feature you’ll be able to find in mattress protectors across the board. Outside of this particular form of protection, things tend to stay rather up in the air from model to model. As such, it’s not only important to know what each protector protects against in the first place, but you should also know what type of protection you’re after before you go into shopping to begin with.

For example, if you’re purely looking for something which can protect your child’s bed against any nighttime accidents, you likely only need a waterproof mattress protector which will prevent against stains. If you’re the type to eat in the bedroom with cutlery, or if you have a day bad-style couch, mattress protectors can be had which are rather resilient to cuts and scrapes. However, the latter feature also introduces its own set of drawbacks, the biggest of which being its level of thickness. If you love your mattress’ outer softness, such a cover will likely ruin this for you. It’s always a good idea to get just the level of protection you need – no more, no less.

Durability or Comfort – You Can Pick One

Of course, a mattress cover’s level of thickness will, in whole or in part, dictate just how durable it truly is. As such, you can be sure that the thickest protector possible will likely give you an above-average level of durability and longevity (though there are perhaps a few other factors at play). On the other hand, a thicker mattress protector will likely take away from the level of comfort already exhibited by your mattress, especially if you have a very soft spring mattress or a memory foam mattress. As such, you’ll have to decide whether you want lots of durability, lots of comfort or a little bit of both.

Do you get hot when you sleep?

Mattress Protector2As with a few modern-day mattresses, there are many mattress covers which “breath” to a certain extent, keeping you somewhat cooler as you sleep. While this can be great in terms of getting an increased level of comfort that your current mattress just can’t provide, you’ll either have to sacrifice other features to get such a model or pay a higher price. On the other hand, if normal mattresses don’t make you hot as you sleep, you likely don’t need a breathable mattress protector in the first place.

Types of Mattress Protection

There are several types of damage your typical mattress protector can prevent. Do you know which types of damage you need protecting against?

  • Stains – The vast majority of mattress protectors are made waterproof. Of course, this is done so to prevent stains. It can also help keep the inner portions of your mattress clean through preventing it from collecting perspiration. Even the most basic of mattress protectors will offer this type of protection.
  • Holes and Scratches – This type of protection is found in a much lower variety of mattress covers. If you know you’ll have sharp objects around the bed (forks, sharp jewelry, etc.), you may find this beneficial. On the other hand, such a mattress protector should only be used when deemed necessary, as this may lower your overall level of comfort through its almost “crunchy” feel.
  • Microbes – Not all mattress protectors come with this form of protection. Despite this, such a feature is very beneficial. Whether you’ve come to realize it or not, the type of damage your mattresses have most accumulated over the years most likely revolves around the collecting microorganisms. With such a mattress cover, those horror stories on the news about dust mites will no longer apply to you.

Common Mattress Protector Features

While whether or not any given mattress protector will work for you comes down to your own personal needs, there are a few features you should want to see in any mattress protector. Here are those features.

  • Hypoallergenic Materials – Whether or not you actually have allergies is, in this sense, largely irrelevant. You’ll find these materials not only to prevent you from experiencing allergy problems, but to keep your mattress from of germs and other microscopic nasties. This is a huge plus that won’t only keep your mattress preserved for a longer amount of time, but will lower the rate at which you find yourself cleaning your mattress protector. It can also be great for overall health, as you can imagine laying in a pile of germs every night isn’t exactly recommended by doctors.
  • Mattress Protector3

  • A Warranty – While a warranty may be a nice added bonus in most products, it is downright essential when it comes to mattress protectors. At the end of the day, you’re buying a product which is meant to protect a piece of equipment for which you paid hundreds or thousands of dollars. If the manufacturer isn’t confident that their protector will work successfully, what does that say about the product? It’s best not to take a chance.


Outside of assuring that your next mattress protector comes with a warranty and fights against germs, which features you decide to look for are up to you to decide. Keep all of the above considerations in mind – or choose a product from the list we went over earlier in the review – to ensure your mattress stays as good as new for years or even decades to come. When it comes to mattresses, it’s just not worth taking a chance.


We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply