Best Fireproof Safe in 2023 – Fireproof Safe Reviews and Ratings

Best Fireproof Safe in 2023 – Fireproof Safe Reviews and Ratings
A fireproof safe is a smart and easy way to protect important document and other items from damage in the event of a fire. Not all safes are the same when it comes to fire protection. It’s important to know what features to look for so you are assured that what you put in the safe is truly protected. When searching for the best of the best in fireproof safes, we considered the top 20 safes on the market and looked at many different factors about these 20. After considering all 20 products, we chose the top three based on a list of criteria that the best fireproof safes possess and have provided the winners to you so you can see if they meet the needs you have for protecting your personal and important items.

1. Honeywell

Best Overall Fireproof Safe

5/5 Product Rating

This 1 hour Fire/Water safe will protect your important documents against fire and water damage.

Documents in this fireproof safe will be protected for an hour in temperatures up to 1700 degrees F.

In addition, the safe protects items from water damage with its waterproof seal and two side compression latches that will keep the contents safe from emergency sprinklers, floods and other types of water damage for as long as 48 hours.

It is the perfect place to store your important personal documents, digital media such as CDs, DVDs, flash drives and other valuables. The size of this fire/water proof safe can accommodate legal sized papers lying flat in the safe. There is a key lock system that protects your documents for added security measures. This item has a convenient carry handle as well.

In the event of a fire, your documents and personal items will be safe, but there will likely be damage to the safe so it is not usable anymore. Honeywell has a 7 year limited warranty with a lifetime after-fire guarantee that provides a new replacement safe if the first one is damaged in a fire.

– Sarah Lytle

2. SentrySafe H2300CG

Best Overall Fireproof Safe – Runner Up

4.9/5 Product Rating

There are many reasons to get the SentrySafe H2300CG Waterproof Fire Chest to keep your important documents and valuables in.

Not only does it protect your valuables from fire with its ETL verified and UL certified ½ fire protection up to 1550 degrees F.

This includes protecting more fragile items such as CDs, DVDs, USB drives and memory sticks that can be even more susceptible to extreme heat, but you will have protection from water damage as well.

The H2300CG has a continuous 360 jamb and waterproof seal that thoroughly protects the interior of the safe and its contents from water getting in. It has a full-time spring latch that seals the safe even when it isn’t officially locked. Give yourself privacy and protection from prying eyes with the privacy key lock.

If the safe is damaged by a fire, SentrySafe has a lifetime after fire guarantee and will replace your safe.

– Sarah Lytle

3. SentrySafe HD4100CG

Best Budget Fireproof Safe

4.8/5 Product Rating

If you’re looking for a reliable and secure place to keep your important documents and other valuables, this SentrySafe Fire-Waterproof Safe is what you need.

This safe is UL classified and has a ½ hour proven fire protection. It also has an ETL verification of ½ hour fire protection for CDs, DVDs USB drivers and memory sticks up to 1550 degrees F.

Another feature is the ETL verification which makes it waterproof as well so your items won’t be damaged if emergency sprinklers go off or flooding occurs.

The privacy key lock protects your important and private documents from others being able to just go through them. Inside the lid there is a holder for your important CDs and DVDs that you want to protect.

Protecting your items from potential fire and water damage is very important. SentrySafe understands this and provides you with the tools you need to do this. It is a good way to give yourself some peace of mind that your important documents are safe in the event of fire or flood.

– Sarah Lytle

Fireproof Safe Buying Guide


Considerations Before Buying

If you have decided that you want to get a fireproof safe to protect your important papers, digital media and other valuables, it is important for you to choose the right one for your specific needs.

The best way to achieve this is to evaluate the different safes on the market and look at the features they offer. Compare these features against the needs you have and you will be able to narrow the field and make the choice much easier.

What are you keeping in your safe?

Every fireproof safe on the market is capable of storing paper documents that you want to protect such as wills, birth certificates, passports and other important papers. If you want to store items such as CDs, DVDs, hard drives, memory sticks, film and other items, you will need to get a special fireproof safe that keeps the internal temperature of the safe below 125 degrees. The more common internal temperature is 350 degrees but this is too hot for those fragile items to stay protected. Knowing ahead of time what you want to keep in your safe will ensure that you get one that has that protection ability.

Other Safe Qualities

    • Waterproof – Many safes are waterproof in addition to being fireproof. This feature is important due to the sprinkler systems that are in many businesses and homes. In addition, if it is waterproof, it can protect valuables from flood damage as well.
    • Impact Resistant – During a fire, floors can fall, supporting beams can collapse and the whole structure can come down. Impact resistance means that the fireproof safe can handle falling from a height and it won’t burst open, ruining everything inside.
    • What Size? – You want to choose a safe that is big enough to keep all of your documents and valuables inside safely. This will vary from home to home. Overall, businesses may have a bigger need for a larger safe than a regular home, but that will also vary. Determine how much you have to put in the safe and then choose the size safe you get accordingly. It’s always better to get one that is a little larger so you can add things to it as needed rather than get one too small and then having to purchase another one.


  • Weight – The larger a safe is, the more it will weigh so take this into consideration when shopping. The place you plan on keeping the safe will need to accommodate the weight safely.
  • Locks – In addition to protecting your valuables and documents from fire and water, you want to protect them from prying eyes as well. This is why a locking system is important. There are several different kinds of locks that fireproof safes have: tubular, deadbolt, combination and electronic. The best and safest lock system to get is the electronic lock that has a backup lock that seals the safe if someone tampers with the main lock.
  • Set a Budget – Fireproof safes can range from $20-$30 dollars up into the hundreds. It is better to set a budget s o you know which safes to look over. There is no point in looking at models that are outside of your budget range. You can go a really good fireproof and waterproof safe for less than $100.

Fire Protection Levels

When looking at different safes, you want to be sure that you understand the fire protection levels that they offer. There are certifications such as UL and ETL that let consumers know what the temperature ratings are and what they have been certified and verified to handle.

Those certifications will tell you the temperature that the fireproof safe is protected to, and for how long. You want to look for a temperature rating that is above 1400, the more above the better, and for a minimum of 1-2 hours.

Burglar Proof

It is a lot more common for theft to occur than to have a fire that destroys your home. For this reason you may want to consider a safe that has some security measures in place as well. The best thing to look at when you are looking to find a secure safe is whether it can be bolted to the floor. That is the best way to ensure the ultimate security because if a burglar can pick the safe up and move it, it doesn’t matter whether the lock is secure or not.

Other features to look for when it comes to theft protection is live locking bolts, recessed doors and hidden hinges which all help protect your private and important documents and valuables safe from theft and prying eyes.


Convenience is important to most people. No one wants to purposely get something that causes them a lot of trouble. The majority of safes come with features that make them convenient for the ones purchasing them. One of the important conveniences is that the fireproof safe should be convenient for you to access whenever you need to.

Look for features like detachable shelves, customizable settings, lighted control or lock panel, and being able to be mounted to a floor or wall. These kinds of features will make the safe a pleasure to own and accessing your valuables when necessary becomes very simple.


If you keep all of these things in mind when you start researching different fireproof safes, you’ll never go wrong. Always make sure you know the answers to the questions of what you will be putting in the safe, where you want to keep it, and the features you want it to have.

The information contained in this buyer’s guide will help the buyer understand what to look for in a safe for your home. With all of the choices available it is beneficial to you to have this information. You will be able to make an informed decision that will fulfill your needs and give you peace of mind that your important, special documents and valuables are safe in the event of fire or flood.


  1. Honeywell –
  2. SentrySafe –
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply