It is not as common today for people to bake their own bread in their homes but if they knew how easy it was to do, they certainly might start. One of the most important factors in choosing a high quality bread pan is choosing one that has the features and capabilities that you are looking for. We looked at the 20 most popular bread pans and considered them for quality of construction, materials used in manufacturing, durability, variety of sizes, reputation of brand and other considerations. The three top rated bread pans featured here were head and shoulders above the rest in all of these categories. Any one of them will make an excellent addition to your baking supplies.
Bread Pan Reviews
You can do a lot with a bread pan including make banana bread, fresh white sandwich bread, raisin breads, French bread and much more. You can also use bread pans for non bread related items like meat loaves, and pot pies.
When you start looking for your perfect bread pan, you will need to consider several things and look at the bread pans you are interested in for certain features. Doing this will help you narrow the choices so you can find the right pan for your kitchen.
1. USA Pan
Best Overall Bread Pan
USA Pan Bakeware Mini Loaf Pan, Set of 4, Nonstick & Quick Release Coating, Made in the USA from Aluminized Steel
3 new from $23.99
as of March 14, 2023 6:28 pm
If you’re looking for a pan that will help you produce perfect, fine grained breads that you can use for sandwiches and even French toast, you will want to get the USA Pan Aluminized Steel Pullman Loaf Pan.
It has a patented Americoat plus nonstick silicone coating that allows for easy release of the bread you bake.
This product is PTFE, PFOA, and BPA free. It has a sliding lid cover that will help you ensure that the bread swells uniformly, creating flat topped bread that your family and friends will love.
The aluminized steel and heavy gauge steel construction promotes even heat distribution and will last decades with the proper care.
The unique fluted surface promotes plenty of air circulation and increases pan strength so they don’t warp. There is steel wire in the rim, giving the pan lots of strength and aides in preventing warping. It is reliable, durable and long lasting bakeware that you will enjoy using. This pan is made from 65% recycled steel and has a lifetime warranty. It measure 9” x 4” x 4” and comes with a convenient cover.
– Sarah Lytle
Best Overall Bread Pan – Runner Up
Focus Foodservice 16 by 4-Inch Single Pullman 2-Pound Bread Pan Commercial Bakeware, 2 Pound, Silver
as of March 14, 2023 6:28 pm
Focus Foodservice offers this heavy duty, commercial grade 2 pound bread pan that will produce delicious bread every time.
The pan measures 16” x 4” x 4” and has a slide on/off cover for convenience. This bread pan has a silicone glaze aluminum steel that gives the products you bake even heat distribution, excellent strength and easy release of the baked goods you bake.
The folded construction and reinforced wire gives the pan plenty of strength and measures .6mm thick.
Users will need to season the pan before using and then wipe clean. Wash with cold water and mild soap and dry it off right away to prevent rust spots from developing. The 3 ply material has two layers of 3003 aluminum alloy that is tough and corrosion resistant.
– Sarah Lytle
3. Silicone Designs
Best Budget Bread Pan
Silicone Bread and Loaf Pan Set of 2 Red, Nonstick, Commercial Grade, Flexible
as of March 14, 2023 6:28 pm
Silicone has become a popular material used in bakeware over the years due to its durability and long lasting properties.
This stylish red bread pan is made from 100% food grade silicone that is BPA and Latex free. It exceeds FDA and LFGB standards. It is family safe and super easy to use and clean.
This bread pan is multipurpose and can be used to bake breads, meatloaf, lasagna and many other delicious foods. It is oven safe to 450 degrees and can also be put in the freezer and microwave.
Each of the bread pans in this set measure 10 ¾” x 5” x 2 ½”. Some of the things people love about using silicone pans are that the bread keeps its shape better and looks more like bread. It also has a softer crust on it than bread makers create.
If you’re looking for a bread pan that will stand up to frequent use, and that will help you produce delicious breads and other foods time and again, you want to get this silicone set. It is dishwasher safe and easy to clean and will last a long time with proper care. There is a free extended warranty when you register the pans and they come with a 100% customer satisfaction guarantee as well.
– Sarah Lytle
Summary of Our Top Picks
Good bread pans are the foundation of excellent bread. When you try and use substandard baking pans to bake with, they can cause sticking and other problems that will ruin the foods you are trying to bake. You won’t have that problem with the top rated bread pans that we have featured above.
All three of these pans are high quality products, made well, with features that put them at the top of the list. From the silicone bread pans that are unique and easy to clean, to the two covered bread pans that will produce 2 pound loaves of fresh, homemade bread, you will never want to go back to store bought bread again.
If you’re not sure if any of the top rated bread pans we have listed are for you, or you just want to learn more about how to choose a great bread pan, read our buyer’s guide below. It is filled with information on choosing the best bread pan you can. This information will help you understand the features to look for when you start shopping for your own bread pans.
Bread Pan Buying Guide
Bread pans are made from many different materials and they come in many shapes and sizes. The standard bread pan is 9” x 5” x 3” but there are many other sizes as well that are available, depending on what your needs are.
The standard size bread pan is perfect for dessert breads, cake loaves and other baked goods and can even be used for meat loaves. We have outlined the different types of bread pans below so you can learn about the differences available.
Types of Bread Pans
- Aluminum – Aluminum is the most popular material that bread pans are made of. It is extremely affordable and provides consistent results. Aluminum conducts heat better than other materials so the bread browns evenly as well as cooks through evenly as well. Nonstick aluminum allows the bread to release from the pan much faster but it can get scratches on it much easier than the unfinished aluminum pans can. Aluminum pans don’t have a long life span, so you will need to plan on replacing them when they need it.
- Silicone – Silicone bread pans are the latest invention in bread pans. They have gained in popularity due to the fact that they have a very fast cool down time and they don’t scratch, dent or oxidize. From the first loaf to the 100th loaf, your silicone pans will look the same. Silicone bread pans are freezer, microwave and oven safe to 450 degrees. They can be washed in the dishwasher as well.
- Stainless Steel – Stainless steel baking pans have a tendency to not heat evenly which can cause problems with the end result. It is liked for the resistance factor since stainless steel is usually very easy to clean and is scratch resistant too. Stainless steel can be more expensive than other types of pans but they will last a long time as well.
- Glass – glass bread pans are not as popular as the other types of pans. It has a tendency to cook the outside faster than the inside which leaves your bread looking fine on the outside and uncooked in the middle. Glass is harder to handle than other types of pans and it can crack, chip and even shatter if it has a bad reaction to heat.
- Stoneware/Ceramic – This type of bread pan has similar problems to watch for that glass pans do which is cracking and chipping. They are very good at cooking evenly. The bread can cook inside while being browned to the perfect degree outside. The more stoneware and ceramic is used the more nonstick it becomes and the more evenly it cooks. A seasoned ceramic or stoneware loaf pan will last a baker for years.
The Importance of Warranties
Make sure that the bread pan that you look at offers a good warranty. You want to be able to have a replacement taken care of in the event the one you have fails. Warranties will vary from brand to brand. You want to get the longest warranty you can find, but don’t let this be the only factor that you consider when choosing the right bread pan.
What Size is the Right Size?
There are many different sizes of bread pans on the market. How do you know what size you need to get? A lot of that will depend on the size of the recipe you are baking from. Below we have listed out typical bread recipes and the size bread pan you would use for each one. This will give you an idea of the size bread pan to purchase.
- If you are making a yeast recipe that has 3 cups of flour or less you will bake that in an 8 ½” x 4 ½” bread pan.
- If your recipe calls for 3 ½ cups of flour and that flour is bread flour or all purpose flour, use a slightly larger bread pan. If it is whole wheat, it will be fine baking in a standard bread pan. If you like combination breads err on the side of caution and opt for the larger size bread pan.
- If you are making a single loaf of bread that has at least 3 ¾ cups of white, whole-grain or combination flour bake your bread in a 9” x 5” pan.
- Some bread recipes call for 4 cups of flour at least. These recipes will need to be baked in a pan larger than 9” x 5”. If all you have is a 9” x 5” pan, bake half the recipe in the 9” x 5” pan and make rolls with the rest of the dough or use two 9” x 5” pans.
There is a large assortment of bread pans on the market today. Choosing from all the different kinds can be confusing and overwhelming unless you know exactly what you want ahead of time. Most people don’t know exactly what they want and many end up just guessing.
With all of these different choices available, it is wise to make sure that you know what your specific needs are. How often will you be using the bread pan? What types of bread do you want to make? How much bread or other type of baked good will you be making? Do you have a preference for a specific type of material?
The answers to these questions are crucial to the bread pans you purchase for your baking needs. Some bakers just use one pan and others may want a variety of sizes to accommodate different size loaves. Whichever you choose, you have to start off with identifying your needs. Once you do that the next steps are much simpler.
The purpose of this buyer’s guide is to provide the baker with the information so they can choose the right bread pan for their needs. Armed with the right knowledge, you can feel confident in your decision and know that you have chosen a bread pan that you will use frequently to produce delicious and well made breads and other baked goods.
- Silicone Designs – http://www.siliconedesigns.com/
- USA Pans – http://www.usapans.com/bakeware.html
- Focus Foodservice – http://focusfoodservice.com/