Top 10 Best Under Eye Concealers

Top 10 Best Under Eye Concealers

We’ve all had those days. You know, the ones where you get up and you’re taken aback by the dark circles and bags? It could be you slept badly. Perhaps you stayed out late or indulged a little too much. Or maybe, you just genetically have dark circles under your eyes. There’s no amount of sleep or hydration that will change that. Thank heavens there are awesome under eye concealers that will tackle dark circles, minimize bags and last all day. Better yet, you’ll find them in a wide array of colors, so finding the right match is a lot simpler than it used to be in the days when everything was fair, medium or dark.

Concealers come in many forms: pencil concealers are almost like eyeliner pencils, and honestly, I’m not a huge fan. They seem harder to blend than most, and make you tug and pull too much on your lower lid, which is awfully delicate skin, to begin with. That’s why you won’t find any of them on my list of favorites. Lipstick or crayon style concealers work wonders and depending on how creamy the formula is, they’re mostly easy to blend. I also think they tend to last longer, especially if set them with a makeup setting spray or powder. (Be light on the powder, though.) There are those nifty liquid concealers that come in a little tube, with a spongy want included, or in tiny tubes to spread with your fingers. They’re super light, but they don’t always have the level of coverage that the sticks and crayons do. And now there are some high quality under eye concealers that come in pots. Despite the fact that I don’t like digging my finger or my nail into them, they do spread beautifully and look really natural.

When you find the right concealer, it can totally change your makeup routine. Used after you’ve let your serum dry, a little concealer can go a long way. Once you’ve blended it, sponge on your tinted moisturizer or foundation, and you’re set. The under eye concealers we’ve reviewed here are true multi-taskers because they’re also great for camouflaging blemishes, dark spots and scars. Some even offer brighteners to light up your eye area and make you look more awake. The great news is that you don’t have to spend a fortune to get a high-quality product. You’ll see several on our list that is highly rated and downright cheap.

No matter which concealer you choose, use it with a light touch. If you need more coverage, choose one that says it’s buildable, meaning you can add layers for extra concealing. I’d definitely encourage you to use blending sponges or concealer brushes to give you the most natural look. 


1. Top Rated Under Eye Concealer: Glo Minerals Concealer Under Eye

best under eye concealer, best undereye concealer, best concealer for dark circles, best concealer, under eye concealer, concealer, glo minerals

Glo Minerals

Glo Minerals Concealer Under Eye offers rich mineral pigments to conceal minor imperfections and create a flawless canvass for your foundation. This under eye concealer offers powerful, clinically advanced ingredients to help improve dark circles, bags, and hyperpigmentation. With two shades, you can blend and customize to perfectly match your skin tone. This concealer is lightweight, but it still delivers great coverage. Because just a little goes a long way, the price point is a bit easier to swallow. It’s also great for concealing dark spots, freckles, and redness. Glo Minerals under eye concealer is talc-free, non-comedogenic and fortified with an exclusive antioxidant blend. Glo Minerals Camouflage Oil Free Concealer is also highly rated and especially effective for concealing acne and acne scarring.

Check out more of the highly rated beauty and makeup products from Glo Minerals right here.

 

Buy the Glo Minerals Concealer Under Eye here.


 


Pros:

  • Rated 4.5 out of five stars by users
  • Lightweight with good coverage
  • You get two colors to better blend with your skin
  • A little goes a long way, so it lasts

Cons:

  • Super spendy
  • Will cake if applied to thickly
  • Doesn’t last as long as some
  • Can seem a bit dry

Find more Glo Minerals Concealer Under Eye information and reviews here.


2. Best Water-Resistant Concealer: AMAZING COSMETICS Amazing Concealer

best under eye concealer, best undereye concealer, best concealer for dark circles, best concealer, under eye concealer, concealer, amazing cosmetics concealer

AMAZING COSMETICS

Amazing Concealer does more than just help hide under eye circles. It is a multi-tasker that is formulated to erase skin imperfections, from under eye circles and blemishes to uneven skin tone and sun damage. Blended properly, it’s almost undetectable on your skin. This cream-based formula is long wearing, and even if you apply it in a thicker coat, it won’t look cakey on your skin. It can also be used to highlight and contour cheekbones, prime and define lips, define and highlight your brow, and contour your nose and jawline. Wow. This under eye concealer is often called the “magic eraser” by professional makeup artists. Mix it with your favorite anti-aging face primer to create a tinted moisturizer. Amazing Concealer is available in 20 shades, so no skin tone is left behind. This concealer is water-resistant, with three times more pigment than most. The downside is that it’s an awfully tiny tube for your money, so you’ll want to use it sparingly, for sure. To create a flawlessly airbrushed finish, try the AMAZING COSMETICS Powder Set. Find more Amazing Concealer colors here.

 

Buy the AMAZING COSMETICS Amazing Concealer here.


 


Pros:

  • Rated 4.5 out of five stars by users
  • Gives a dewy natural look
  • Lasts throughout the day and is water resistant
  • Doesn’t get cakey

Cons:

  • Tiny tube with a big price tag
  • Smell is a bit off
  • Colors tend to have yellowish undertones
  • Might be too expensive fore everyday use

Find more AMAZING COSMETICS Amazing Concealer information and reviews here.

 

3. jane iredale Active Light Under Eye Concealer

best under eye concealer, best undereye concealer, best concealer for dark circles, best concealer, under eye concealer, concealer, jane iredale

jane iredale

This creamy under eye concealer helps to reduce puffiness, which is a definite plus in my book. It also refracts light, to give your face a soft-focus finish. It can be used as a facial highlighter as well. This concealer delivers sheer to medium coverage for dark circles and under-eye shadows. The brush is specifically designed to fit easily into the hard to reach recess between the nose and the inner corner of the eye. When selecting a color of this concealer, you can choose which fits your needs best by using their easy to follow guidelines. Colors one and two are yellow based, which neutralizes redness. Colors three and four are peach based, to neutralize blue, violet and grey tones, which is perfect dark under eye circles. Number five is yellow/brown based, to neutralize redness in darker skin tones. Number six is orange/brown based, which neutralizes brown and black in darker skin tones. The natural ingredient list for this concealer is impressive too, with buckwheat seed extract to reduce puffiness, cucumber fruit extract to soothe, and white tea leaf extracts calm, soothe, and protect your delicate under eye skin. You can also blend and apply this concealer with a flocked sponge to give your concealer a smooth, all day finish.

Browse for more luxurious Jane Iredale cosmetics and skin care products here.

 

Buy the jane iredale Active Light Under Eye Concealer here.


 


Pros:

  • Rated 4.2 out of five stars by users
  • Covers dark circles and blemishes too
  • Comes with a specially designed brush
  • Silky smooth and brightens as well as conceals

Cons:

  • Spendy for such a small tube
  • Not as long lasting as some
  • Brush head can deliver too much concealer
  • Not enough coverage for some

Find more jane iredale Active Light Under Eye Concealer information and reviews here.

 

4. Dermablend Smooth Liquid Concealer

best under eye concealer, best undereye concealer, best concealer for dark circles, best concealer, under eye concealer, concealer, dermablend

Dermablend was once known for their premier line of foundations that covered even the most serious scars. Now their products fit even mainstream users like us. Their all-purpose liquid concealer is a good case in point. It goes on smooth and gives you even, medium coverage. This buildable, lightweight concealer also gives your sensitive under eye area much needed hydration. It covers, corrects and masks skin imperfections, from uneven skin tone to under eye circles, providing seamless camouflage of anything you’d prefer to hide. Ophthalmologist and dermatologist-tested, this concealer is fragrance-free, allergy-tested, non-comedogenic and non-acnegenic. To give you up to 16 hours of coverage, simply apply setting powder afterward, and give yourself a spritz of rosewater to make it last. For a creamy, full-coverage concealer that’s easy to toss in your purse for a touch up, the Dermablend Quick-fix Concealer Stick is a terrific choice. If redness, rosacea and pimples are your biggest issues, Dermablend Smooth Indulgence Rednesss Green Concealer is a #1 Amazon New Release.

 

Buy the Dermablend Smooth Liquid Concealer here.


 


Pros:

  • Rated 4.2 out of five stars by users
  • Gives high performance medium coverage of dark circles, acne scars and redness
  • Non-comedogenic and non-acnegenic
  • Fragrance free

Cons:

  • More expensive than many
  • Too thin for some
  • Doesn’t provide enough coverage for some users
  • Can feel a bit chalky

Find more Dermablend Smooth Liquid Concealer information and reviews here.


 

5. Best Brightening Concealer: bareMinerals Stroke of Light Eye Brightener

best under eye concealer, best undereye concealer, best concealer for dark circles, best concealer, under eye concealer, concealer, bareminerals

bareMinerals

bareMinerals Stroke of Light Eye Brightener is an under eye concealer that diffuses dark shadows while visibly reducing fine lines and dark circles. It instantly illuminates and brightens the under eye area, but doesn’t sink into the your tiny lines and wrinkles. Just dab it on over your primer and blend for all day coverage. Just a light touch can cover those problematic dark circles. The creamy formula doesn’t cake, and it’s lightweight, so it’s a great chice for those of you who prefer a minimal makeup routine. It’s also a great product for highlighting your brow bone, nose, cheekbones and any other facial feature you’d like to stand out. And of course, you can use it to touch up light blemishes as well. If you need a full coverage concealer, bareMinerals BareSkin Complete Coverage Concealer is a silky smooth complete coverage concealer and serum in one. The highly rated bareMinerals Correcting Concealer is enriched with SPF 20. This multi-tasking concealer will also protect your skin from the sun’s harmful UVA/UVB rays.

 

Buy the bareMinerals Stroke of Light Eye Brightener here.


 


Pros:

  • Rated 4.4 out of five stars by users
  • Lightens and brightens dark circles
  • Can be used for highlighting other areas of your face
  • Doesn’t sink into fine lines or accentuate wrinkles

Cons:

  • Too oily for some users
  • It can look a bit too sparkly
  • May irritate eyes
  • Text here

Find more bareMinerals Stroke of Light Eye Brightener information and reviews here.


 

6. Best Buy: Maybelline New York Instant Age Rewind Eraser Dark Circles Treatment Concealer

best under eye concealer, best undereye concealer, best concealer for dark circles, best concealer, under eye concealer, concealer, maybelline

Maybelline New York

You’ll love this concealer with its micro-corrector applicator that fills and smooths fine lines. This formula uses Haloxyl to reduce the look of puffiness and under-eye shadows, while fading the appearance of under-eye circles. It instantly creates a more radiant, refreshed looking eye area. The super concentrated formula is also infused with goji berry to visibly diminishing the appearance of puffiness around the eyes. The soft, sponge tip does a great job of allowing you to gently dab on the concealer, which features a neutralizer to diminish dark blue and purple circles or scarring and never cakes, even after hours of wear. Even a thick coat blends well and leaves your under eye area looking lighter, brighter and more awake. For natural coverage that lightweight and breathable, Maybelline New York Fit Me! Concealer is also well rated at 4.3 out of five stars. If you prefer a stick over a liquid concealer, Maybelline New York Dream Brightening Creamy Concealer is an easy-to-use crayon that gives you medium to full coverage with a luminous finish.

 

Buy the Maybelline New York Instant Age Rewind Eraser Dark Circles Treatment Concealer here.


 


Pros:

  • Rated 4.3 out of five stars by users
  • Super affordable
  • Effectively covers dark circles and brightens eye area
  • Doesn’t cake or seep into creases and wrinkles

Cons:

  • Harder to blend than some
  • Difficult to get out of the applicator tip at first
  • Can be drying to skin
  • Thinner than some formulas requiring you to use more product

Find more Maybelline New York Instant Age Rewind Eraser Dark Circles Treatment Concealer information and reviews here.

 

7. Revlon Photoready Concealer

best under eye concealer, best undereye concealer, best concealer for dark circles, best concealer, under eye concealer, concealer, revlon

Revlon

Revlon Photoready Concealer is designed with innovative photochromatic pigments that bend, reflect and diffuse light to give you a flawless airbrushed appearance in any light. This stick style concealer is supremely blendable, creamy easy to apply using the stick or your fingers. Once blended, just set with powder and get all day wear without it sinking into creases. It’s also great for covering blemishes and freckles as well as dark under eye circles. Users love it for its performance, but most especially for its affordability. If you’re a person with dark circles, it’s easy to go through a lot of concealer with daily use, so the price is a total bonus. It provides medium to full coverage, along with brightness to make your eyes more awake and alive looking. For the most flawless results, start with the Revlon Photoready Perfecting Primer under your makeup, and follow up by sponging on the Revlon Photoready Airbrush Effect Makeup, which comes in twelve shades to give you a perfect color match.

 

Buy the Revlon Photoready Concealer here.


 


Pros:

  • Rated 4.3 out of five stars by users
  • Very easy to apply
  • Blendable and buildable
  • Downright cheap

Cons:

  • Stick can break inside tube
  • Not enough coverage for some
  • Doesn’t last as long as some other brands
  • The highlighters can look a bit too glittery

Find more Revlon Photoready Concealer information and reviews here.


 

8. It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Full Coverage Waterproof Concealer

best under eye concealer, best undereye concealer, best concealer for dark circles, best concealer, under eye concealer, concealer, it cosmetics

It Cosmetics

Fortified with collagen, and vitamins C and K, plus antioxidants, this multipurpose concealer covers dark circles, bags and discoloration pretty instantly. The skin-loving ingredients work to moisturize the delicate under eye area, which provides a helpful anti-aging benefit. The concealer goes on quite tacky, but lasts well throughout the day. The tiniest drop can be gently blended with the It Cosmetics Luxe Concealer Brush to deliver great coverage of dark circles and conceal bags. The fact that it’s waterproof gives you security knowing you can hit the gym, pool or any other demanding activity and your concealer will stay in place. It’s also perfect for covering blemishes without causing your skin to break out, despite its moisturizing formula. We also love the fact that it’s cruelty free with no animal testing. Finish your face with the It Cosmetics Bye Bye Pores HD Micro, Finishing Powder for a flawless look that lasts until bedtime.

 

Buy the It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Full Coverage Waterproof Concealer here.


 


Pros:

  • Rated 4.3 out of five stars by users
  • Collagen and antioxidants help moisturize and conceal
  • A little goes a long way
  • Waterproof formula is safe for the gym, pool or other sweaty endeavors

Cons:

  • A tiny tube for substantial cash
  • Tacky formula can be difficult to squeeze out of the tube
  • More difficult to blend without pulling on sensitive under eye tissues
  • Tends to accentuate fine lines and wrinkes

Find more It Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Full Coverage Waterproof Concealer information and reviews here.


 

9. NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer

best under eye concealer, best undereye concealer, best concealer for dark circles, best concealer, under eye concealer, concealer, nars cosmetics

NARS

Some people refer to the NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer as the holy grail of all concealers. It’s long wearing and crease-proof formula comes in ten colors, which makes finding the right one for you a bit easier. It’s super-blendable and delivers full coverage to target dark circles, dark spots and other blemishes. The convenient sponge applicator means you can dab it on a tiny bit at a time and build for how much coverage you want. This formula is paraben-free, alcohol free, synthetic fragrance free, and noncomedogenic. It really does an effective job at covering most skin flaws, other than those crusty kind, in which case, they almost stand out more. Sorry folks, that’s pretty much the case with all concealers. As wildly popular as this under eye concealer is, NARS has come out with a new product that is getting raves early on. While there aren’t enough full reviews for us to give it the nod in this post, keep your eyes out because the NARS Soft Matte Complete Concealer looks like it’s going to be their new heavy hitter. For an ultralight look without heavy foundation, the NARS Pure Radiant Tinted Moisturizer gives you a glowing complexion and features broad spectrum SPF 30 to boot.

 

Buy the NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer here.


 


Pros:

  • Rated 4.3 out of five stars by users
  • Effectively covers dark circles and acne scars
  • A little goes a long way
  • Blends beautifully

Cons:

  • Awfully expensive
  • Tends to crease if applied to thickly
  • Not enough coverage for some users
  • Some packing issues reported

Find more NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer information and reviews here.


 

10. Best Natural Vegan Under Eye Concealer: Ecco Bella FlowerColor All Natural Cover Up

best under eye concealer, best undereye concealer, best concealer for dark circles, best concealer, under eye concealer, concealer, ecco bella

Ecco Bella

Because we’re in love with Ecco Bella FlowerColor lipsticks, it wasn’t a huge leap to fall for their under eye concealer too. Because it doesn’t contain any toxins or chemicals to dry and irritate your skin and eyes, it feels safe to use it in such a sensitive area. This formula is made of natural ingredients, free of talc, fragrance, dyes and gluten, so it won’t cause breakouts. This concealer glides on easily to cover dark circles around your eyes, blemishes or other skin imperfections, and it looks smooth when it’s blended in. All Ecco Bella FlowerColor makeup is infused with flower wax to last all day long. The same coating that protects flower petals from the elements, can do the same for your makeup. This light and creamy formula is fairly mistake-proof, and, it won’t dry the delicate skin around your eyes.

Browse here for more vegan, natural, organic and cruelty free cosmetics from Ecco Bella.

 

Buy the Ecco Bella FlowerColor All Natural Cover Up here.


 


Pros:

  • Rated four out of five stars by users
  • Amazon’s Choice
  • Goes on smooth and blends easily
  • Good coverage of dark circles, blemishes and more
  • Nice, natural ingredient list

Cons:

  • Can seem a bit oily
  • Not as long lasting as some
  • Stick can too easily break inside the tube
  • Color runs dark

Find more Ecco Bella FlowerColor All Natural Cover Up information and reviews here.

774 total views, 20 views today

About Shelby Parrish 73 Articles
Shelby Parrish is a single mom of 2. She enjoys researching and writing on products that have to do with family, Babies and Health. She was a Business Developer for a top SEO firm in Boston before she resigned to focus on producing high quality consumer guides for consumers on the internet. When she's not working online to create awesome unbiased reviews, she's busy listening to podcasts on fitness and healthy living.